CoinSchool — Indian Numismatic Reference & Auction Archive

Indian Coin Grading Scale Explained: Fine, VF, XF, UNC and the Sheldon Numbers

By Rahul Gupta, CoinSchool · Updated

Grade is the single biggest influence on what a coin sells for after rarity: the same Victoria rupee can bring a few hundred rupees in Fine and many thousands in choice Uncirculated. Indian auction catalogues describe grade in words — Fine, Very Fine, Extremely Fine, About UNC, UNC — while slabbed coins from NGC and PCGS carry a Sheldon number from 1 to 70. This guide explains both, shows what each grade looks like, and covers the special cases of hand-struck and ancient coins.

To grade a coin in hand, answer the questions in the free Coin Grading tool; it returns the Sheldon number, the catalogue wording and realised prices grade by grade.

Free tools for this guide: Coin Grading tool · Label Maker (print the grade) · Auction archive

The grades, in order

Catalogue wordingAbbrev.SheldonWhat you see
Poor / FairP, Fr1–3Type identifiable, most detail and legend gone, rims worn into the design.
About Good / GoodAG, G3–6Outline of the design, legend partly readable, rim merging with letters.
Very GoodVG8–10Full legend readable, design flat with little inner detail.
FineF12–15Moderate even wear; major details clear, hair and feathers mostly flat.
Very FineVF20–35Light wear on the high points only; most hair, drapery and lettering sharp.
Extremely FineXF / EF40–45Slight wear on the very highest points; traces of mint lustre.
About UncirculatedAU / aUNC50–58Trace of friction on the highest points; most lustre present.
Uncirculated / Mint StateUNC / MS60–70No wear at all; MS-60 may have bag marks, MS-65 and above are choice to gem.

Indian cataloguers add qualifiers: “about VF” sits below VF, “good VF” above it, and “choice” or “gem” mark the top of UNC. Prefixes such as “details” or “cleaned” mean the coin has the detail of that grade but a problem that lowers its value.

Where to look for wear

Wear begins on the highest points of the relief. On British India coins check Victoria’s hair above the ear and the ribbon, the crown jewels on the Empress bust, George V’s moustache and crown, and the central lotus or wreath on the reverse. On Republic coins check the Lion Capital’s mane and the lettering. On Mughal rupees look at the raised tops of the letters and the dotted borders. Lustre — the cartwheel sheen of a fresh strike — survives first in the protected fields between letters.

Hand-struck coins are graded differently

Sultanate, Mughal, princely-state and early East India Company coins were struck by hand on flans smaller than the die. Two things that are not wear decide their appeal: the strike (how much of the die is on the flan, how crisply it was struck) and the flan (shape, cracks, test marks). A hand-struck rupee can be fully Uncirculated yet show only half the legend; a cataloguer will write “UNC, 70% legend” or “full flan”. Weak strike must not be confused with wear: a weakly struck area is smooth and unlustred from the start, while a worn area is flat with scratches and a lustre break around it.

Ancient coins — punch-marked, Kushan, Gupta — are graded on the completeness and clarity of the symbols and legend as much as on wear, and catalogues often say “well-centred” or “all five symbols on flan” instead of a grade.

Problem coins: cleaned, holed, mounted, tooled

A problem does not change the detail grade but it changes the price, often by half or more. The common ones on Indian coins are: cleaning (unnaturally bright silver with hairline scratches), test marks and shroff marks (small punches by money-changers, very common on Mughal and princely rupees and accepted as normal on early issues), holes and mount marks from jewellery, chopmarks on trade coins, tooling (re-engraved detail) and corrosion on excavated copper. Describe them honestly; buyers at auction will find them anyway.

Third-party grading in India

NGC and PCGS slabs are increasingly common in Indian auctions, especially for British India and gold. They grade on the Sheldon scale, add designations such as PL (proof-like) and note problems as “details”. A slab costs more than most Republic and common British India coins are worth, so it is used for scarce dates, gold and top grades. The grade on the slab is an opinion; two services can differ by a point.

How much does grade change the price?

For a common British India silver rupee the price roughly doubles from Fine to VF, doubles again to XF, and multiplies several times from XF to choice UNC, because collectors compete for the few surviving mint-state pieces. For hand-struck coins a full-flan, well-centred specimen commands the premium that UNC does for machine-struck coins. The Coin Grading tool shows realised prices grade by grade for any coin you name, read from the CoinSchool auction archive; the old coin value guide explains how to use them.

Frequently asked questions

What does VF mean on a coin?
Very Fine: light, even wear confined to the highest points of the design, with most detail and the full legend sharp. On the Sheldon scale it covers VF-20 to VF-35.

What is the difference between XF and UNC?
An Extremely Fine coin shows slight wear on the very highest points and traces of lustre; an Uncirculated coin has no wear at all, though it may have contact marks from the mint bag.

How are Mughal coins graded if the legend is off the flan?
By wear and strike separately: a cataloguer grades the surfaces (for example UNC) and states how much of the legend or die is on the flan (for example “80% legend” or “full flan”). Off-flan legend is not wear.

Are test marks a problem on old Indian rupees?
Small shroff or test marks are normal on Mughal, princely-state and early Company rupees and reduce value only when large or disfiguring. On British India coins they are treated as damage.

Should I clean a coin before grading or selling?
No. Cleaning removes lustre and leaves hairlines; a cleaned coin is described as such and sells for less. Leave toning alone.

Related guides: How much is my coin worth? · How to sell old coins in India · How to photograph coins · Identify an old Indian coin · All guides · All tools

CoinSchool Auction Archive
Realised prices for 450,000+ Indian & world coins from Todywalla, Classical Numismatic Gallery, Bombay Auctions, Virasat, Jain and Stephen Album sales.
Search the full archive free →

Home · Auction Archive · Free Coin Tools · Coin Photo Editor · Coin Line Drawing Tool · Guides · Identify a Coin · Coin Value · Coin Grading · Label Maker · News · Coin Agent · Sell Old Coins · Contact · ❤️ Donate · ✨ Ad-free · About · Privacy · Terms · Refunds